Incident Timeline
Click any incident to expand full details, quotes, and legal relevance. All 15+ documented incidents in chronological order.
Evidence Library
Add links directly in the browser. Click any item to open. Pull this up in court to access any document instantly. Add new items using the form in each tab.
Maynard v. Luckett
Primary Goal: Full déchéance de l'autorité parentale — complete termination of Maurice Luckett's parental authority under Article 606 C.c.Q. Secondary goals (child support, debt contribution) are sought only if achievable alongside déchéance — never at the cost of the primary goal.
Six Pillars of the Case
Each pillar independently supports déchéance under Article 606 C.c.Q. Together they form an overwhelming evidentiary foundation. Primary objective: full severance. Child support and debt recovery are secondary and pursued only if compatible with severance.
His Own Words
Every quote below is Maurice Luckett's own statement — written, recorded, or publicly published. No interpretation required.
Article 606 C.c.Q. — The Law
Current as of June 6, 2023. The 2022–2023 amendments significantly strengthened grounds for déchéance by explicitly naming conjugal violence.
Case Precedents
Add and remove precedents as you research. Each entry links directly to the case. Click the case link to open the full judgment.
His Anticipated Claims — Context & Response
Click any claim to expand the full context and response. Every item has a documented, specific, contextual answer. None constitute coercive control — they are reactions to documented triggers, not initiating patterns.
Notary Defense: The agreement was signed before a notary, whose role is to confirm voluntary signing without duress. He raised no objection at the time. He cannot now claim coercion without explaining why he signed voluntarily before an independent officer of the law.
His Own Words Defeat This Claim: In the same text exchange where he called it blackmail, he ultimately agreed: "Yes, I'll stop talking about breaking up." A person under genuine coercion does not negotiate and then comply.
The Distinction: Coercive control uses movement restriction to isolate and dominate. Fiona raised concerns rooted in specific documented behavior. Courts trained in domestic violence understand the difference between control and reaction to breach of trust.
Function Is Different: Monitoring someone who has expressed desire to die is a safety response, not surveillance. Courts assess the function of behavior. His location requests for her had no equivalent safety rationale.
Mutuality Defense: The day after this incident, Maurice made the same request of Fiona — asking her to kneel in apology. She complied. This establishes the gesture as a mutual dynamic in their relationship. A person who genuinely experienced racial trauma does not then use the identical gesture as a power tool the following day.
Race Weaponization Pattern: Throughout the relationship, Maurice documented using racial accusations as a control mechanism — claiming identical behaviors were acceptable when he did them but racist when Fiona did them. This pattern is documented in text exchanges.
His own disclosures (PTSD hyperarousal, hypervigilance, social withdrawal) describe difficulty with sustained social engagement due to his condition, not due to Fiona's restrictions. His Instagram Live describes himself as someone who burns his previous life and plants in new soil — suggesting social isolation predates this relationship entirely.
Additionally: he has been attending VA therapy for years. His 100% disability rating is maintained despite that attendance — confirming the condition is severe and treatment-resistant, not that therapy was withheld.
Categorical Difference: Fiona's statement was relational exhaustion, immediately followed by a commitment to communication and forgiveness. Maurice's pattern: handwritten suicide note (Nov 2024), published self-harm account cutting his forearm 4 inches (Substack, 2020), second phone threat post-separation (Oct 2025). One is rhetorical distress, self-explained. The other is a documented multi-year clinical pattern across different life circumstances.
Context: Several items (Door Knob, Peanut Gallery, Kid) are common expressions not typically understood as racial slurs — his framing of these as racist is itself an example of the documented pattern of weaponizing race to control conversations. The remaining labels are characterizations of his behavior in reactive moments during conflict.
Asymmetry: His verbal abuse: "FUCK YOU" with physical head-thrust aggression, "you being white is not the only reason I don't like you, I don't like you because you're a bitch," "slut." One side has a documented initiating pattern. The other has reactive responses.
Most Revealing Part of His List: The same document contains his statement that Fiona "offered her body to demons" and that he used "Seraphim energy to remove demons from her stomach, lungs and intestines" and freed her mother from "a debt to The Shadow Realm." Presented as factual reality during an argument — among the strongest evidence of disconnection from shared reality.
The Irony: Maurice threatened to leave and packed his bags on four documented occasions. His July 29, 2025 departure — nine days after Scarlett's birthday, subsequently publicly glorified — is the actual documented sustained absence in this case. An 8-hour visit to a sister with location active does not constitute child abduction by any legal standard.
For Bianca — Questions & Notes
A private space for counsel to add questions, flag items, or note follow-up actions. Click any note body to edit it directly. Add new notes with the button below.
Key Emails to Counsel
Key communications sent to Me Scaramuzzi for reference.